Showing posts with label BiologicalRecording. Show all posts
Showing posts with label BiologicalRecording. Show all posts

Saturday, 29 August 2026

What we're missing

Netelia cristata, 5th VC55 record

Netelia cristata

Over the past few years I've tried (and pretty much failed) to convince colleagues that it is a scientific and ethical imperative to at least try to analyze the bycatch from insect trapping, including but not limited to light traps. Blinded by the light (sorry, moths), I can't seem to convince people to make the effort. One notable exception is my colleague Graham who regularly sends me samples from his amazingly productive garden moth trap. Working together we have clocked up an ever growing list of new species for VC55, including many solitary wasps.

Parasitoid wasps, usually overlooked, are crucial for understanding ecosystems and environmental change. Capitalising on other projects such as the bycatch from moth trapping can provide valuable insights into these overlooked taxa at relatively low additional cost or effort. A new article describes the use of an existing citizen science project, the National Moth Recording Scheme, to monitor nocturnal parasitoid wasps in the UK. The researchers collaborated with moth-trappers to collect "bycatch" from light traps, focusing on Ichneumonidae, a family of parasitoid wasps. Over five months in 2024, they collected 6,779 specimens, representing over 184 taxa. The project successfully collected a majority of previously recorded UK nocturnal Ichneumons within the five month period (e.g. 82% of Netelia, 91% of Ophion) and provided new species records for 67 of the 71 sampled species in 82 of 91 sampled vice-counties, including some rare species.
Cunningham-Eurich, I., Aucock, L., Walters-Hutton, B., Sumner, S. & Broad, G.R. (2026) Moth traps shine a light on nocturnal parasitoid wasps: Snapshot assessment of UK diversity and distributions. Insect Conservation and Diversity, 1–23. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1111/icad.70135

Plenty of research shows the effectiveness of UV LED trapping for a wide range of insect taxa, so as soon as it stops raining I'm aiming to use my newly acquired LED strings to figure out what's flying about out there in the dark.  


See also: Dietenberger, M., Jechow, A., Sann, M., & Hölker, F. (2025) Shedding light on dark taxa: exploring a cryptic diversity of parasitoid wasps affected by artificial light at night. Scientific reports, 15(1), 6237. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-025-88111-3




Tuesday, 14 October 2025

Spiders of the Rutland Water Lagoons

Spiders of the Rutland Water Lagoons

Palmer, P., Cann, A., Sexton, T., Fox, B., & Pitt-Miller, S. (2025) Spiders of the Rutland Water Lagoons: An Exploratory Survey. ISBN 979-8269245362 Available at: https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B0FVMMK466

"This report tells the story of an ambitious survey of invertebrates at Rutland Water nature reserve in England. We used pitfall traps across several lagoons, hoping to focus on spiders but deciding to record everything we caught. Around sixty traps went out. Some were lost to flooding, others raided by crows. Even so, more than a thousand spiders were recovered, along with a by-catch of beetles and other groups. The work was far bigger than we expected. It took time, energy, and patience to bring the results together. Four years later - and with help from many generous volunteers - we are at last ready to share the findings. This report covers only the spider records."

 




Tuesday, 17 June 2025

The Pattern

Scarce Silver-lines, Bena bicolorana

In the past, 36 moths of 20 species in the garden moth trap on a warm June evening would have felt like a famine, but now it feels like the best I can hope for. Of these, two were new for the garden, including this Scarce Silver-lines, Bena bicolorana. This is the pattern I am seeing now - reasonable numbers of species but overall, hugely reduced numbers of insects, and diversity lower than in the past. 
 

Tuesday, 6 May 2025

Bees Knees - Minding The Gap

Bee collage

It's been a good year for bees so far - the weather has suited them. Last month I found an interesting mining bee in my garden. Leicestershire has fairly good bee records, but they are mostly focussed on bumblebees. The solitary bees (and even more so solitary wasps) are a black hole in recording, particularly when it comes to verification of records. Solitary Hymenoptera in general are a vast and growing skills gap in our knowledge. Partly spurred by curiosity at my find and partly by guilt, I bought a copy of the excellent Falk and Lewington field guide and set off on a quest (Falk, S. (2019) Field guide to the bees of Great Britain and Ireland. Bloomsbury Publishing). 

I wasn't expecting it to be easy, which is good because it's not. This is not an area where casual recorders are ever going to make much impact beyond a handful of species. Nevertheless, I'm enjoying the challenge although I wouldn't have got very far with the field guide alone and without the support of the highly knowledgeable online bee communities. Whether I'll be able to make any sort of impact when it comes to the skills gap it's far too early to say. 

 





Friday, 27 December 2024

FIT Count Summary 2024

FIT Count Summary 2024
The UK Pollinator Monitoring Scheme (UK PoMS) launched FIT Counts (Flower-Insect Timed Counts) in the UK several years ago. At the time, I decided not to bother. This year, with the moth trap in my suburban garden not justifying the electricity to run it (other than to document the disastrous local decline in flying insect numbers this year), FIT Counts seemed much more attractive. For one thing, FIT COUNTS are a very low carbon way of recording - in good weather, spend ten minutes watching flowers and insects in your garden or local park, then upload the results via a mobile phone app or the website. I'm usually disappointed by big citizen science projects, which tend towards engagement rather than useful data, but the FIT Count methodology is geared towards long term monitoring which is desperately needed. 

UK POMS has just sent all the recorders an end of year summary - short version: another record year for FIT Counts. My own effort is a sad four sessions, but I'm looking forward to the start of the FIT Count season (1st April - 30th September) and making a better effort next year. With 2024 virtually certain to be the warmest year ever and the first year to exceed 1.5°C above pre-industrial levels, this sort of data becomes ever more important, as does gathering it without getting in your car and driving off to get it. The two most important groups of pollinators, bees and flies are both vulnerable to climate change between these two major groups of pollinators, with flies seemingly being more at risk. Even 10 minutes standing watching your local insects can help. How hard can that be? 

Critical thermal maxima differ between groups of insect pollinators and their foraging times: Implications for their responses to climate change. Journal of Melittology, (122), 2024.
 

Thursday, 25 July 2024

FIT Counts

FIT Count Logo

The UK Pollinator Monitoring Scheme (UK PoMS) launched FIT Counts (Flower-Insect Timed Counts) in the UK several years ago. At the time, I decided not to bother. This year, with the moth trap in my suburban garden not justifying the electricity to run it (other than to document the disastrous decline in flying insect numbers this year), FIT Counts seem much more attractive. For one thing, they are a very low carbon way of recording - in good weather, spend ten minutes watching flowers and insects in your garden or local park, then upload the results via a mobile phone app or the website. I'm usually disappointed by big citizen science projects, which tend towards engagement rather than useful data, but the FIT Count methodology is geared towards long term monitoring which is desperately needed. Please give it a go. It could become a habit. 

 

Friday, 22 December 2023

Happy Entomological Christmas

 Winter solstice greetings, with a look back at my entomological 2023. 

DALL·E3/Bing Image Creator
DALL·E3/Bing Image Creator

For me 2023 hasn't been a vintage recording year for a number of reasons. After the extreme heat of summer 2022, a cold snap in December and a wet winter, the year got off to a slow start. By the end of January I was desperate enough to try beating Box (Buxus sempervirens), a plant I've never investigated before. Via Anthocoris butleri, this started off a journey through the genus Anthocoris which in some ways has been the highlight of the year, and certainly good for my skills. Writing now at the end of the year we only have one Anthocoris species still missing in VC55, the appropriately seasonal Anthocoris viscii. Mistletoe is now quite plentiful here, but inaccessible high in the trees so I'm hopeful that Santa will bring me that drone with a vacuum sampler attached. 

Spring seemed to drag on and at times I despaired about the general lack of insects. In April, things started to improve, but mostly because I'd done something to help - I bought myself a dip net. Armed with this I started touring VC55 ponds and water courses recording aquatic bugs. This was hugely enjoyable, and working on live aquatic bugs is so much more enjoyable than dead moth trap specimens covered in scales! The only issue I had was one encounter with an elderly dragon who berated me for stealing tadpoles! I narrowly managed to escape being beaten with her rolled up umbrella and she remained utterly sceptical of my excuses about aquatic Homoptera. (Note: net is thoroughly disinfected between each site.)

In May I decided to repeat the trick and bought my first ever sweep net. I'd always been resistant to sweep netting, partly to avoid looking like a Victorian butterfly collector, but I now see the error of my ways. In the field the sweep net was both a blessing and a curse. At the times when I didn't want a lengthy conversation, I could easily sidestep because the usual civilian opener was "Are you looking for Butterflies?" (as in - What else to people catch in nets?), to which I could simply reply "Yes". (I wasn't.) The downside was the aggressive reaction from the off-lead dog plague at all of our nature reserves and SSSIs. Dogs really don't like sweepnets. Neither do dog owners - "You're upsetting him". 

It wasn't until June that things really picked up and on the 30th of June I have a very clear memory of standing in one of the rides at Prior's Coppice that was absolutely alive with insects. What a relief after the famine of spring! Armed with my new net I collected spiders, but mostly focused on Hemiptera, and in particular Mirids. I was looking forward to Carry On Sweep Netting into the autumn and adding to my Auchenorrhyncha records but at this point things started to go awry. In July it started raining and this carried on into August. Good for dip netting, not for sweep nettting. Personal circumstances then got in the way and I wasn't able to do much recording for several months, not even running the moth trap in the garden (bloody builders!). In September I was dragged off on holiday and deliberately didn't do any recording as I was feeling stale and in need of a break. 

Come October things improved and entomological activity started up again. I gave two talks on Mastigusa macrophthalma and while I was spouting my ecological theories about this species I had a lightbulb moment. This resulted in my second most enjoyable field visit of the year (after the relief of Prior's Coppice) - a day spent (successfully) poking around the 800 year Oaks in Bradate Park (first Oak-associated VC55 record for M. macrophthalma in 55 years). 

In November Santa came early and brought me a new camera I could slip in my pocket for macro photos in the field. This revitalized my recording, even though there wasn't much about by this stage of the year and many sites were still too wet to visit. The unexpected cold snap at the end of November and into December put paid to my recording year, apart from a late flourish from the Ivy. Overall, it's been a pretty average year, but I have done some new things and those have been the highlights. 

I don't do new year resolutions but it is good to have some specific targets for the coming year. The main one is to continue with the new collection methods I used this year - dip net, sweep net - and to avoid going to the same sites at the same time of year and collecting samples in the same way. Hopefully the ponds won't dry up in summer so I can continue dip netting into the autumn. The other objective is to run the garden moth trap on a regular basis! In addition, I have a cunning plan based on a remark that Jim Flanagan made in an online talk ... but more of that next year. 

The best thing about 2023 overall has been all the people I have worked with - face to face and online. I hope to be more sociable next year! 

 

Friday, 9 June 2023

Monitoring and Benchmarking Insects

Useful paper with a comparison of entomological methods for surveys. Marred only by the fact that it fails to consider spiders! 

Montgomery, G. A., Belitz, M. W., Guralnick, R. P., & Tingley, M. W. (2021). Standards and best practices for monitoring and benchmarking insects. Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution, 513. https://doi.org/10.3389/fevo.2020.579193

"Benchmark studies of insect populations are increasingly relevant and needed amid accelerating concern about insect trends in the Anthropocene. The growing recognition that insect populations may be in decline has given rise to a renewed call for insect population monitoring by scientists, and a desire from the broader public to participate in insect surveys. However, due to the immense diversity of insects and a vast assortment of data collection methods, there is a general lack of standardization in insect monitoring methods, such that a sudden and unplanned expansion of data collection may fail to meet its ecological potential or conservation needs without a coordinated focus on standards and best practices. To begin to address this problem, we provide simple guidelines for maximizing return on proven inventory methods that will provide insect benchmarking data suitable for a variety of ecological responses, including occurrence and distribution, phenology, abundance and biomass, and diversity and species composition. To track these responses, we present seven primary insect sampling methods—malaise trapping, light trapping, pan trapping, pitfall trappings, beating sheets, acoustic monitoring, and active visual surveys—and recommend standards while highlighting examples of model programs. For each method, we discuss key topics such as recommended spatial and temporal scales of sampling, important metadata to track, and degree of replication needed to produce rigorous estimates of ecological responses. We additionally suggest protocols for scalable insect monitoring, from backyards to national parks. Overall, we aim to compile a resource that can be used by diverse individuals and organizations seeking to initiate or improve insect monitoring programs in this era of rapid change."

 


Thursday, 29 December 2022

2022 - My Year in Spiders

 I would sum up 2022 as quality over quantity...

2022 Spiders

I haven't been able to spend as much time as I would have liked on spidering this year, but I'm still pretty pleased with the outcome. The weather has been challenging with alternating exceptional droughts, rainfall and the highest temperature ever recorded here. Although the number of specimens I recorded was well down, I managed to make some nice finds. Here are my highlights.


Megalepthyphantes sp. near collinus

Megalepthyphantes nr collinus

The year started well in January when I was refurbishing an old garden pond into a bog garden and found a specimen of Megalepthyphantes sp. near collinus which I eventually managed to identify with help, a horticultural import I suspect and the first record for VC55.


Leptorhoptrum robustum

Leptorhoptrum robustum
This Linyphiid turned up on a streamside survey in March as part of a local river restoration project, one of two projects to which I have devoted field time this year. An inhabitant of the local sewage works, these spiders work their way downstream and I have found them at several places along the watercourse, showing just how much restoration is needed.


Mastigusa macrophthalma

Mastigusa macrophthalma
I "refound" the "Charnwood Spider" in VC55 after a gap of twenty years as part the other large landscape project I have been contributing to this year. The first specimens turned up in March at one of the species strongholds, but I was subsequently able to find it at another site where it had never been recorded. More importantly, I was able to confirm that it was not present (following on from decades of arachnological work) at quite a few other sites which look eminently suitable but where it is just absent. I only recently worked out why this is, so I think this quest will be continuing next year.


Textrix denticulata

Textrix denticulata
This attractive spider was a by-product of searching for Mastigusa. This species is not common in VC55, or at least it is not commonly recorded, but I found it at a number of different locations, partial compensation for drawing a blank with Mastigusa on most field trips.


Mangora acalypha

Mangora acalypha

This orb-weaver has only spread to VC55 very recently and the few records have been from a garden so it was a pleasant surprise to find it on Gorse in a rural location. This one is clearly on the move. 


Arctosa leopardus

Arctosa leopardus
I found this attractive wolf spider in a riverside sample in May when I was desperately targeting damp places after the spring drought. Much of my time this year has been taken up slogging though hundreds of pitfall trap samples from a large 2021 survey at Rutland Water which turned up several specimens of this species - the first records for VC55. My specimen came from the opposite side of the vice-county, so it is clearly established on different drainages and it is strange that this species has not been recorded before.



Collinsia distincta


Collinsia distincta

This Linyphiid came from the same riverside sample as Arctosa leopardus, making this a productive trip. The first record for VC55 for this species.


Lophomma punctatum

Lophomma punctatum

As if two weren't enough, the same sample also produced a specimen of Lophomma punctatum. This spider is well known from the County but not often recorded so it was a nice addition.


Oonops domesticus

Oonops domesticus

Last and very definitely least (size-wise!), Oonops domesticus paid me its triennial visit in October. I only seem to see this spider in my house every three years or so but it is always a welcome sight - one of my favourites. 

 



Monday, 28 March 2022

Old Big-Eyes is Back

 Quiz time! Which species of spider is this the natural habitat of? 

Habitat

One of them is Textrix denticulata, not particularly common in Leicestershire:

Textrix denticulata
In January I was asked by the Charnwood Forest Landscape Partnership scheme if I could help refind the "Charnwood Spider", Mastigusa macrophthalma. This species was last recorded in Leicestershire 20 years ago, and on Charnwood 21 years ago. Rashly, I said yes, but bearing in mind some good arachnologists have been surveying on Charnwood in recent years, privately I had my doubts. For various reasons, I haven't been able to do much fieldwork yet this year, but recently I was able to revisit one of the last known Charwood sites for the species.

Mastigusa macrophthalma

Mastigusa macrophthalma

Mastigusa macrophthalma


Success :-)

The other interesting thing about this record is that the spider was associating with Formica lemani (thanks to Gavin Gamble and Matt Hamer for the ID) under the rock, which I have not seen listed as a known associate for this species elsewhere:

Formica lemani

I'm delighted to have been able to see and photograph this magnificant spider (now back under its home rock after a few photographs). However, I do worry a lot about the amount of disturbance and pressure on the site. My next move, having got my eye in, is to try and find new sites for the species, clinging to its ancient Charnwood home by its teeny tiny claws. 

 







Thursday, 8 October 2020

Florodelphax leptosoma - a new planthopper for VC55

I recently picked up a useful field tip. If you're like me, there are certain species which you know well but can never remember the names of. The trick is to give them a name you can remember, then look them up when you get home. Among the hoppers (Auchenorrhyncha), the Planthoppers (family Delphacidae) are easy to assign to a family (large, apical movable spur on the hind tibiae), but mostly tricky to identify to species level. One exception is Conomelus anceps, which I find at almost every site I visit - but can never remember the name of:

Conomelus anceps

I have been able to resolve this difficult by christening them "Minions". Problem solved. 

On a recent trip to New Lount, a few small dark Minions stood out from the crowd in the tray. On examination, these turned out to be Florodelphax leptosoma:

Florodelphax leptosoma

This is a fairly common species found in a wide range of wetland habitats across the UK, but the fact that it has never been recorded previously in VC55 points to how seriously under-recorded the Auchenorrhyncha are as a group. 
 

Thursday, 16 April 2020

Wild and Wacky (We are the Robots)



When I talked about spider recording in VC55 a couple of months ago, the discussion quickly became "imaginative", and by the end of the meeting, we had "decided" ;-) to equip a drone with an eVac and program it to fly a 10m grid covering the whole of VC55 taking samples. These would need to be sorted by hand to sort out the [insert taxon of choice, e.g. spiders] from the debris, and then sent off for DNA barcoding (High-throughput sequencing for community analysis: the promise of DNA barcoding to uncover diversity, relatedness, abundances and interactions in spider communities (2020) Development Genes and Evolution volume 230, 185–201). Not good news if you're an ecological consultant, great news for gene jockeys.

Mass sampling projects are "easy" to set up. "Hey, I know, let's sequence the whole of Wytham Woods." There was another one published yesterday (Changes in phenology and abundance of suction‐trapped Diptera from a farmland site in the UK over four decades. (2020) Ecol Entomol). What's not easy is processing the data they produce. It took the Danes 15 years to record the results of their malaise traps (The Swedish Malaise Trap Project: A 15 Year Retrospective on a Countrywide Insect Inventory (2020) Biodiversity Data Journal 8: e47255). Right now DNA barcoding is the only feasible way of tackling the mass of data such projects produce. But maybe not for much longer. A.I. (Artificial Intelligence) is coming: A light trap and computer vision system to detect and classify live moths (Lepidoptera) using tracking and deep learning. (2020) bioRxiv https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.03.18.996447, and: Successful launch of automatic insect counting in North Holland. I've been concerned about the impact of A.I. for some time. Well, not about A.I. as such, more about A.S. - the poorly functioning first generation systems - Artificial Stupidity. It's not there yet, but inevitably it will come.

Recently I've noticed a disturbing trend in entomology blog posts to include dodgy music videos. Until the A.I. finally takes over, it seems that We are the Robots:



Monday, 25 November 2019

Filling the White Holes

I'm growing increasingly obsessed with data that isn't there... Earlier this month Dom Greaves used the phrase White Holes on Twitter:



It stuck in my mind and I haven't been able to shift it. Previously, I've used R to plot heatmaps of VC55 (Leicestershire and Rutland) spider records (all VC55 spider records (>43k) to end 2018, data copyright Leicestershire and Rutland Environmental Records Centre) (click images for larger versions):



However, the problem with heatmaps is that they inevitably focus attention on where the data is, rather than where it is missing. As an attempt to try to switch the emphasis I tried quadrat mapping - arbitrarily dividing VC55 into a grid and looking at the number of records within each section. Initially I tried a 50x50 grid but with 43,000 records, that choked my computer. A 25x25 grid worked but the the intervals were a bit small and a 10x10 grid is more informative:



Conveniently, R gives the record counts for each tile:



and plotting a histogram of the counts draws attention to how skewed the distribution of records is. Result!



The method isn't prefect. The tiles and hence the counts are of unequal area where they overlap the VC55 boundary, but I don't know how you get around that, with the possible exception that plotting the data by parish rather than by quadrat might be better?

The other place I'm currently stuck is trying to turn unstructured data into occupancy models. This is another White Hole Problem, but one that continues to defeat me.


Acknowledgements:
  • All data Copyright Leicestershire and Rutland Environmental Records Centre.
  • Data visualization performed using the R platform, v. 3.6.1 (R Core Team (2014) R: A language and environment for statistical computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria. http://www.R-project.org).
  • J. Cann for assistance with data visualization.

Thursday, 24 October 2019

How to do biological recording

An interesting new preprint addresses an issue I've been concerned about for a while, how to control for recording effort in assessing how species are doing (Rapid assessment of the suitability of multi-species citizen science datasets for occupancy trend analysis: https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/813626v1).

The biggest volume of biological data is recorded by unstructured citizen science schemes. Because the data is collected in an essentially random way, many taxon experts are sceptical about the value of these schemes in accurately reflecting populations in the field. Although the statistics are complicated, the method of the new paper seeks to turn unstructured data into occurrence data, i.e. data where we can be sure (to any specified degree) of the presence or absence of a species in a given time period, or the absence of sufficient data to make a determination. The method to do this is to call each 1km grid square a recording site and to count the number of visits each year, one visit constituting one record by any person in a 24 hour period. From this it is possible to calculate the degree of confidence in the occurrence or absence of a species at the site. Ideally (for high confidence) there would be four or more visits from experienced recorders per site per year, but even in the absence of this, the method provides a way of turning the massive amount of unstructured biological recording data available into findings which are easier to interpret and to place confidence limits on.


(click for larger image)

Unsurprisingly, it turns out that butterflies and moths are the runaway winners, the East Midlands performs creditably, and species which get a lot of publicity do better than those for which there are only a handful of experts who can identify them. Nevertheless, if tools could be developed to enable easy utilisation of the method, this would present a valuable way forwards.


(click for larger image)


Note: R package "unmarked" is of relevance: https://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/unmarked/index.html